Not that the world needed yet another fan blog about a TV show, but after a very interesting Season 7, I felt more convinced than ever that this show would benefit from having a judge on its panel each week who is merely a fan - not a choreographer, producer, or Hollywood bigwig. The Judges (capital "J" when referring to The Main Trio) might find themselves a bit more in tune with the audience if they actually ever bothered to ask why the audience votes the way it does. So, to be purely self-serving and egomaniacal, I have appointed myself "the SYTYCD Fan Judge" (until such time as the show appoints one), and with that, here is yet another fan blog about a TV show...

Wednesday, August 22, 2012

Top 10 Perform


Opening Number:  Wonderful tribute to Gene Kelly – and props to Tyce Diorio for his dancing, as well as his choreography! 

Tiffany & Brandon – Doriana Sanchez disco:  WOW!!  I am thrilled that Brandon is back as an all-star, although I thought it was a little unfortunate that he got disco.  Then again, in his season, he had the best disco in the show’s history, so I suppose that makes sense.  That is, it was the best disco - until tonight!  THAT. WAS. AWESOME!  There was just nothing about that dance that did not work – the music was great, the choreography was both challenging and in the spirit of disco, their personalities were lively, and damn if they weren’t just on FIRE with their energy.  Outstanding, and I’m glad I don’t have to be the one to follow them!

Witney & Nick – Travis Wall: That was so COOL!  Once again, Travis Wall ROCKS. MY. WORLD.  (Okay, done overusing the already overused all-caps, extra periods thing.)  What a fantastic hybrid of contemporary and ballroom, and a unique take on the “dead dancers” storyline, and of course, the dancing was fabulous. 

Cole & Anya – Dmitry cha-cha:  Well, I can see this is just going to be a night chock-full of awesomeness.  Yowza!  I have to say Cole creeps me out ever so slightly, but that does not remotely mitigate the extraordinary talent he has on the dance floor.  I didn’t see quite what Mary saw; I thought he was doing his part to hold up the chemistry, but as I’ve thought with Anya before, she seemed a little vacant to me   Maybe Nigel has a point that he was performing more to the audience than to Anya, but I’m still not convinced that’s his fault.  Hubby thinks Anya looked a shade out of shape; also possible, but I just think she wasn’t fully checked in, and that hurt Cole with the judges – but not with me!

Lindsay & Jakob – Spencer Liff Broadway:  YAAAAAAAAAAAAY, JAKOB’S BACK!!!!  *Kermit-the-Frog wavy arms*  I have been waiting for this moment!  And lucky me, it was capped off by:  Spencer Liff choreography.  ???  REALLY???  WHY do they keep letting that horrifically incapable man choreograph on this show???  *sigh*  Okay, in spite of that, Lindsay (and of COURSE Jakob)?  Incredible.  They managed to make that routine (which wasn’t Spencer’s horriblest) eminently enjoyable, and I genuinely saw the Broadway in Lindsay.  LOVED IT.  (And THANK YOU, Nigel, for bringing Jakob back!  IT’S ABOUT TIME!)

Will & Kathryn – Nakul Bollywood:  I mean…rrrreeeeaaalllllyyy, to use an old Cat Deeley phrase.  That was full of energy and spunk, sensuality and silliness (in the way that Bollywood should be).  Kathryn, ever beautiful, was the perfect snake to be charmed That was thoroughly entertaining, and I am so glad they continue to put Bollywood routines in these shows.

Cyrus & Jaimie – Travis Wall contemporary:  Uh-oh, it finally happened – Cyrus got contemporary.  So, to all you naysayers who thought Cyrus would be screwed when he finally got contemporary, all I have to say is:  how ya’ like me now?  Travis did not dumb that routine down one iota, so I don’t wanna hear any nonsense about how it wasn’t a challenging enough routine.  No, his leap wasn’t executed the way Jakob would’ve done it, but did his performance lack in this dance?  Nuh-uh.  It is so obvious how hard he works and how much he puts into every single dance, and I am thrilled that he survived this competition long enough for us to see that particular performance.

Chehon & Lauren – Dave Scott hip-hop:  You know, on another night, that might’ve been better for me than it was tonight.  In light of the other routines, I thought this was okay.  I thought Chehon performed well, but I felt like he was a ballet dancer in a hip-hop routine (which, while true, should not have been so evident).  Granted, Dave Scott created a very fluid routine which facilitated Chehon’s style, but I think that actually did him a disservice because it didn’t give him any…well, “buck-ness.”  It was by no means a bad dance, but it wasn’t exceptional the way the other routines tonight were. 

George & Allison – Tyce Diorio jazz:  First words out of my husband’s mouth:  “Great dance!”  Meanwhile, I was thinking:  “Hm.  Not my favorite genre…still, the choreography was challenging…Allison is smoldering hot…but George, while performing well, just doesn’t seem to be connecting with her, per se…”  Huh.  So, what a relief to me when Nigel said exactly what was on my mind.  Thank goodness, because I was beginning to think it was just me!  Sorry, I adore George, but the chemistry just wasn’t there, especially given the premise of the number.

Eliana & Alex – Stacey Tookey contemporary:  I’m sorry, let me get this straight:  I get to watch Eliana – and ALEX – do a Stacey Tookey contemporary routine?  Um, short of Jakob joining in, I can’t think of a more ideal set-up.  And yet… I think, honestly, it was a routine I’d rather have seen on another night.  It was such a change of pace from all the hyperkinetically-charged numbers we’ve seen so far, that it just felt almost out of place.  That said, it was lovely.  Nigel pegged it right in terms of the strengths – the maturity, the intensity…  it was a terrific routine, but I just didn’t feel like I enjoyed it to its fullest, and I can only imagine it musta been the context of the other numbers.

Audrey & Twitch – Dave Scott hip-hop:  That was entertaining, and a smidge of hilarious, but I’m not sure that Audrey wasn’t just a little too cute for that routine.  I think Benjamin had a point about her being a little outshone by Twitch’s stardom, especially in this genre.  She wasn’t at all buck, although I have to admit it kinda worked for her character to be a bit more peppy.  We’ll see how the voting goes.

And now, for the bad news…

The Bottom Four: 

You know, I so enjoyed this show, that I honestly forgot we had to lose someone at the end.  And wow, Witney and Audrey are the bottom two??  Oy.  I mean, there is not going to be any satisfying answer, especially among the women, but…wow.  I do think Chehon and George are probably the right answers for the guys, but it’s still unfortunate.  I’m glad they opted to have them do solos – although I feel confident the judges have already made up their minds.  All four soloes were terrific, and I’m glad I didn’t have to choose.  (Note:  loved the LA Dance Project performance!)

The Goodbyes:

I must say, while I think there was no right answer, I was a little surprised they ultimately picked Audrey to go home.  I am guessing they think Witney is a smidge more marketable, but otherwise, I kinda thought Audrey’d be the keeper.  As for the guys, that was less of a surprise.  I think they both have their struggles, but I think George’s brink-of-ouster last week was a little fresher, and I think his performance tonight didn’t help.  I hate seeing either one of these folks go, but at this point, there are going to be no good goodbyes.  We’ll just have to set our sights on seeing them both on tour!

And then there were eight…

No comments:

Post a Comment